WHO STRATEGIC AND TECHNICAL ADVISORY GROUP ON TB (STAG)
2007 REPORT PUBLISHED
The full report of the seventh meeting of the Strategic and Technical Advisory Group for TB (STAG-TB) is now published and contains a series of recommendations to WHO. STAG-TB's mission is to contribute to global tuberculosis control by providing state-of the-art scientific and technical guidance to WHO.
October 2007 -- The full report of the seventh meeting of the Strategic and Technical Advisory Group for TB (STAG-TB) is now published. It contains a series of recommendations to WHO, including endorsements of:
the planned global response to MDR-TB / XDR-TB;
the ongoing response to the TB emergencies in Africa and Europe;
the use of liquid culture for TB diagnosis;
a revised TB case definition;
WHO's planned role in the Stop TB Partnership's TB research movement;
WHO guidance and plans to support community involvement in TB care, control and prevention.
STAG-TB's mission is to contribute to global tuberculosis control by providing state-of the-art scientific and technical guidance to WHO. International experts and implementers in TB care and control, research and civil society participated in the meeting, held in June 2007 at WHO headquarters in Geneva.
The
World Health Organization has been in the forefront
of the struggle to eradicate TB worldwide.
Goals:
to reduce TB morbidity and deaths by
promoting the world-wide use of DOTS and
other effective TB control strategies
to assess existing strategies, and develop
new strategies for the prevention and
control of TB through operational, epidemiological,
and economic research
Objectives:
to develop a global plan for the control
and prevention of TB, and to assist countries
in its implementation
to promote the wide-spread use of DOTS;
the potential of this cheap and effective
strategy to reduce TB morbidity and deaths
has not yet been realized in all settings
to assess the impact of DOTS in specific
settings and globally
to design new approaches to TB control
addressing the specific problems of TB/HIV,
drug resistance and inequalities in access
to health services
TOWARDS
A TB-FREE FUTURE - GLOBAL
PLAN
THE
PURPOSE OF THE GLOBAL PLAN
To eliminate tuberculosis (TB) as a public
health problem. That and nothing less is
the goal of the global Stop TB Partnership.
We know it will not happen overnight with
a disease that has cast a centuries-long
shadow; still, that is our aim-and we can
achieve it.
The Global Plan to Stop
TB (GPSTB) assesses the threat of TB based
on the most current global evidence. At
the same time, it shows why we are confident
that TB can be controlled and, eventually,
eliminated. The Global Plan describes mechanisms
and activities that are already in place,
as well as resources urgently needed over
the next five years to accelerate our efforts
to meet the new global TB control targets.
We can control TB. With TB, in contrast
to some other modern plagues, we know what
needs to be done, we know how to do it and
we know how much it will cost. If we effectively
apply proven and cost effective strategies
for TB control, adapting and improving them
to meet the challenges described in this
document over the next five years, we will
have taken a giant step towards eliminating
tuberculosis as a threat to future generations.
THE
OBJECTIVES
The Global Plan has four objectives:
To expand
our current strategy- DOTS-so that all
people with TB have access to effective
diagnosis and treatment.
To adapt
this strategy to meet the emerging challenges
of HIV and drug resistance.
To improve
existing tools by developing new diagnostics,
new drugs, and a new vaccine.
To strengthen
the Stop TB Partnership so that proven
TB control strategies are effectively
applied.
A plan is only as good
as the effective action it generates.
PLAN
COSTS
Effective TB control cannot be imposed from
above. National governments and local communities
must take responsibility for planning and
implementing their TB prevention and treatment
programmes.
WHAT WILL BE ACCOMPLISHED? This plan
lays out what needs to be done if we are
to control, and eventually eliminate, TB.
It describes the strategies and the mechanisms
to achieve our goals and what these accomplishments
will cost.
What will have been accomplished if we meet
the goals of this plan?
The 22 countries that account for 80%
of the world's TB burden will have rapidly
expanded DOTS and met control targets-detecting
70% of people with infectious TB, and
successfully treating 85% of those detected.
More than four million patients will
survive their tuberculosis through detection
and treatment in these newly expanded
DOTS programmes. If DOTS programmes are
not expanded, they will
suffer and die from their disease and
infect numerous friends and family members
along the way.
We will have defined, adopted and implemented
effective strategies to address HIV-related
TB.
We will have incorporated DOTS-Plus
protocols for MDR-TB into the DOTS strategy.
We will have an improved TB diagnostic
test for use in high-burden countries.
Five new anti-TB drug candidates will
have completed pre-clinical trials.
There will be at least one TB vaccine
candidate in clinical trials to test efficacy.
These are enormous accomplishments, planned
to counter an equally enormous threat
to the health, well-being and development
of communities throughout the world. We
can control TB. With this plan, Stop TB
partners around the world are on the way
to doing so. But we need
your help. Come join us in delivering
this "splendid gift" to the
generations of the Third Millennium-ending
this debilitating disease that we have
the capacity to cure.
Threat
of the Global Epidemic
Tuberculosis
(TB) kills approximately 2 million people
each year. The global epidemic is growing
and becoming more dangerous. The breakdown
in health services, the spread of HIV/AIDS
and the emergence of multidrug-resistant
TB are contributing to the worsening impact
of this disease.
In 1993, the World Health
Organization (WHO) took an unprecedented
step and declared tuberculosis a global
emergency, so great was the concern about
the modern TB epidemic.
It is estimated that between
2002 and 2020, approximately 1000 million
people will be newly infected, over 150
million people will get sick, and 36 million
will die of TB - if control is not further
strengthened.
Infection
and Transmission
TB
is a contagious disease. Like the common
cold, it spreads through the air. Only people
who are sick with pulmonary TB are infectious.
When infectious people cough, sneeze, talk
or spit, they propel TB germs, known as
bacilli, into the air. A person needs only
to inhale a small number of these to be
infected.
Left untreated, each person
with active TB will infect on average between
10 and 15 people every year. But people
infected with TB will not necessarily get
sick with the disease. The immune system
'walls off' the TB bacilli which, protected
by a thick waxy coat, can lie dormant for
years. When someone's immune system is weakened,
the chances of getting sick are greater.
Someone in the world is newly infected
with TB every second.
Nearly 1% of the world's population
is newly infected with TB each year.
Overall, one third of the world's population
is currently infected with the TB bacillus.
5-10% of people who are infected with
TB (but who are not infected with HIV)
become sick or infectious at some time
during their life.
Global and Regional Incidence
Each year, more people
are dying of TB. In Eastern Europe and Africa,
TB deaths are increasing after almost 40
years of decline. In terms of numbers of
cases, the biggest burden of TB is in south-east
Asia.
Factors
Contributing to the Rise in TB
TB kills about 2 million people each
year (including persons infected with
HIV).
More than 8 million people become sick
with TB each year.
About 2 million TB cases per year occur
in sub-Saharan Africa. This number is
rising rapidly as a result of the HIV/AIDS
epidemic.
Around 3 million TB cases per year occur
in south-east Asia.
Over a quarter of a million TB cases
per year occur in Eastern Europe.
HIV
is accelerating the spread of TB
HIV and TB form a
lethal combination, each speeding the other's
progress. HIV weakens the immune system.
Someone who is HIV-positive and infected
with TB is many times more likely to become
sick with TB than someone infected with
TB who is HIV-negative. TB is a leading
cause of death among people who are HIV-positive.
It accounts for about 11% of AIDS deaths
worldwide. In Africa, HIV is the single
most important factor determining the increased
incidence of TB in the past 10 years.
Poorly
managed TB programmes are threatening to
make TB incurable
Until 50 years ago, there were no drugs
to cure TB. Now, strains that are resistant
to a single drug have been documented in
every country surveyed and, what is more,
strains of TB resistant to all major anti-TB
drugs have emerged. Drug-resistant TB is
caused by inconsistent or partial treatment,
when patients do not take all their drugs
regularly for the required period because
they start to feel better, doctors and health
workers prescribe the wrong treatment regimens
or the drug supply is unreliable. A particularly
dangerous form of drug-resistant TB is multidrug-resistant
TB (MDR-TB), which is defined as the disease
due to TB the two most powerful-bacilli
resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampicin
anti-TB drugs. Rates of MDR-TB are high
in some countries, especially in the former
Soviet Union, and threaten TB control efforts.
From a public health perspective,
poorly supervised or incomplete treatment
of TB is worse than no treatment at all.
When people fail to complete standard treatment
regimens, or are given the wrong treatment
regimen, they may remain infectious. The
bacilli in their lungs may develop resistance
to anti-TB drugs. People they infect will
have the same drug-resistant strain. While
drug-resistant TB is treatable, it requires
extensive chemotherapy (up to two years
of treatment) that is often prohibitively
expensive (often more than 100 times more
expensive than treatment of drug-susceptible
TB), and is also more toxic to patients.
WHO and its international
partners have formed the DOTS-Plus Working
Group , which is attempting to determine
the best possible strategy to manage MDR-TB.
One of the goals of DOTS-Plus is to increase
access to expensive second-line anti-TB
drugs for WHO-approved TB control programmes
in low- and middle-income countries.
Movement
of people is helping the spread of TB
Global trade and the number of people travelling
in aeroplanes have increased dramatically
over the past 40 years. In many industrialized
countries, at least one-half of TB cases
are among foreign-born people. In the United
States, nearly 40% of TB cases are among
foreign-born people.
The number of refugees
and displaced people in the world is also
increasing. Untreated TB spreads quickly
in crowded refugee camps and shelters. It
is difficult to treat mobile populations,
as treatment takes at least six months and
should ideally be suvervised. As many as
50% of the world's refugees could be infected
with TB. As they move, they may spread TB.
Effective
TB Control
The WHO-recommended treatment strategy for
detection and cure of TB is DOTS. DOTS combines
five elements: political commitment, microscopy
services, drug supplies, surveillance and
monitoring systems and use of highly efficacious
regimes with direct observation of treatment.
Once patients with infectious
TB (bacilli visible in a sputum smear) have
been identified using microscopy services,
health and community workers and trained
volunteers observe patients swallowing the
full course of the correct dosage of anti-TB
medicines (treatment lasts six to eight
months). The most common anti-TB drugs are
isoniazid, rifampicin, pyrazinamide, streptomycin
and ethambutol.
Sputum smear testing is
repeated after two months, to check progress,
and again at the end of treatment. A recording
and reporting system documents patients'
progress throughout, and the final outcome
of treatment.
Since DOTS was introduced
on a global scale in 1991, about 10 million
patients have received DOTS treatment. In
half of China, cure rates among new cases
are 96%. In Peru, widespread use of DOTS
for more than five years has led to the
successful treatment of 91 %of cases and
a decline in incidence.
By the end of 2000, all
22 of the highest burden countries which
bear 80% of the world's estimated incident
cases had adopted DOTS. Fifty-five percent
of the global population had access to DOTS,
double the fraction reported in 1995. In
the same year, 27% of estimated TB patients
received treatment under DOTS, two and a
half times the fraction reported in 1995.
DOTS produces cure rates of up to 95%
even in the poorest countries.
DOTS prevents new infections by curing
infectious patients.
DOTS prevents the development of MDR-TB
by ensuring the full course of treatment
is followed.
A six-month supply of drugs for DOTS
costs as little as US$ 10 per patient
in some parts of the world.
The World Bank has ranked the DOTS strategy
as one of the "most cost-effective
of all health interventions."
WHO targets are to detect
70% of new infectious TB cases and to cure
85% of those detected. Ten countries had
achieved these targets in 2000. Governments,
nongovernmental organizations and civil
society must continue to act to improve
TB control if we are to reach these targets
worldwide.
Country
Profiles: India
India
has provided an environment in which tuberculosis
can thrive. Because the disease carries
a social stigma, many leave treatment too
soon, becoming chronic and drug-resistant
cases. TB has often been misdiagnosed and
treated ineffectively. Drug supplies have
been erratic. Against these odds, India
today is prepared to fight and defeat TB.
Where
TB Has Lurked in the Shadows, New Light
Breaks Through
Among the more than 900
million people in India today, every second
adult is infected with the tuberculosis
bacterium. Each year, more than 2 million
people develop active tuberculosis, and
up to 500,000 people die. The pool of infection
– and the resulting risk of becoming
infected with the disease – is as
great as in any country on earth.
Tuberculosis carries a
heavy stigma, and rejection by neighbors,
employers and co-workers is still a fear
of TB patients in many communities. Young
brides who develop symptoms of tuberculosis
could in many cases expect to be returned
to their parents as unfit to bear children,
their dowries forfeited.
The problems facing effective
tuberculosis control in India appear at
first glance to be much the same as those
that too often exist throughout much of
southern Asia. There are real and potential
conflicts between the interests of private
physicians and the public sector. The quality
and supply of drugs is erratic. Errors in
diagnosis, based predominantly on X-ray
and sometimes symptoms alone, are common.
Infectious cases are frequently missed,
while other people are mistakenly diagnosed
with TB and inappropriately treated. Training,
support and supervision of staff is not
adequate. In some places, morale among health
workers has been low.
As a result, at least two
thirds of TB patients have dropped out of
treatment early, often becoming chronic
sufferers; sources of infection to others.
Very often these chronic cases become incubators
for deadly drug-resistant bacteria.
Against this outlook pointing
to a dark future, India has decided to take
decisive action to halt the spread of tuberculosis.
The core strategy: shrink the pool of contagion
and the risk of becoming infected with the
disease by attacking TB aggressively. To
date, a strategy consistent with DOTS has
been applied in demonstration areas covering
over 12 million people. This strategy has
achieved a cure rate over 80 percent among
detected patients.
In fact, several of the
fundamental principles of DOTS were first
developed in India. The ability to treat
TB patients effectively at home, without
the cost and duress of hospitalization,
was first tested and documented in India
in the 1950s and 60s.
Everyone's
Problem
In these pilot areas, staff
receive intensive training in the DOTS strategy.
Microscopy services for sputum testing are
in place; and a new drug supply system procures
drugs and supplies high-quality medications.
With this community-based
system, health workers watch their patients
take and swallow their drugs. This additional
responsibility – which might have
overwhelmed busy health workers –
now serves to raise these health workers'
status in their communities and to motivate
them to approach this important work with
real dedication.
Patients have responded
positively in most cases to the DOTS strategy.
The personal attention of the DOTS strategy
makes them feel cared for. The strategy
also shows them that they can be cured of
TB without going to a private doctor –
who usually charges a fee they can seldom
afford and then fails to achieve a real
cure. Today, in the pilot DOTS areas, the
drop-out rate from treatment has plummeted.
Tuberculosis is now cured in 4 out of every
5 patients.
The
Challenge of Expansion
The DOTS pilot projects
have demonstrated convincingly that supervised
short-course treatment can work in India.
Some states, like Kerala, have already begun
to implement the DOTS strategy in new districts
and plan to provide ready access to DOTS
treatment for all TB patients within a few
years.
With support from the World
Bank, the DOTS strategy is now being expanded
gradually throughout the country. A first
step will be to cover 270 million people
in 102 districts during the first five year
phase from 1997 to 2002. At the same time,
systematic reporting and monitoring of patient
outcomes and a regular drug supply system
will be set up in preparation for further
expansion to the whole population.
As the DOTS treatment network
is being built, India must pay close attention
to the interests of the private practitioners
who have long treated TB patients on a fee
basis. It is pivotal to incorporate this
key group into the DOTS expansion process,
and to provide them a role in tuberculosis
control. Practitioners who see DOTS as a
financial threat could undermine the programme.
The success of the pilot
programmes have shown patients that tuberculosis
can be cured, and health workers that their
efforts can save lives. Demand for DOTS
services has grown and momentum continues
to build. No less important, the stigma
attached to tuberculosis can now begin to
diminish.
2,058,600
new TB cases annually - 82% DOTS cure rate!
Assessment
- India
Several
of the fundamental principles of DOTS were
first developed in India. The ability to
treat TB patients effectively at home, without
the cost and duress of hospitalization,
was first tested and documented in India
in the 1950s and 60s.
WHO declares
TB an emergency in Africa Call for "urgent
and extraordinary actions” to halt worsening
epidemic
The
World Health Organization (WHO) Regional
Committee for Africa comprising health ministers
from 46 Member States has declared tuberculosis
an emergency in the African region - a response
to an epidemic that has more than quadrupled
the annual number of new TB cases in most
African countries since 1990 and is continuing
to rise across the continent, killing more
than half a million people every year.
The declaration was made in a resolution
adopted today at the end of the Committee's
fifty-fifth session in Maputo, Mozambique.
The resolution urges Member States in the
African Region to commit more human and
financial resources to strengthen DOTS programmes
and scale up collaborative interventions
to fight the co-epidemic of TB and HIV.
These and other measures recommended by
the Committee encompass those laid out in
a "blueprint" developed by the
global Stop TB Partnership, which calls
for US $2.2 billion in new funding for TB
control in Africa during 2006-2007.
"Despite commendable efforts by countries
and partners to control tuberculosis, impact
on incidence has not been significant and
the epidemic has now reached unprecedented
proportions,” said WHO Regional Director
for Africa, Dr. Luis Gomes Sambo. “Urgent
and extraordinary actions must be taken,
or else the situation will only get worse
and the TB targets in the Abuja Declaration
and the Millennium Development Goals will
not be achieved."
Globally, TB is second only to HIV/AIDS
as a cause of illness and death of adults,
accounting for nearly nine million cases
of active disease and two million deaths
every year. Although it has only 11% of
the world's population, Africa accounts
today for more than a quarter of this global
burden with an estimated 2.4 million TB
cases and 540,000 TB deaths annually.
In the late 1970s and early 1980s, African
countries like Tanzania, Mozambique and
Malawi were among the first to apply what
became the global TB control strategy now
known as DOTS. But in the past 15 years,
TB incidence rates have soared in the region
- to as high as four-fold in Malawi and
five-fold in Kenya, to cite some typical
examples -due largely to the link with HIV/AIDS,
poverty and weak health systems. Although
countries have made efforts to treat the
rising tide of TB cases, they are still
being outpaced by the epidemic.
"It is tragic that this disease has
not been brought under control, because
I am living proof that TB can be effectively
treated and cured," said Nobel laureate
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, who along with
former South African President Nelson Mandela
is a survivor of the disease. "The
problem is huge and medical authorities
cannot overcome it alone, they need help.
A full course of TB drugs that costs 15
dollars will save the lives of TB patients
- and in the case of people who are co-infected
with HIV, extend their lives by precious
years until ARVs become more widely available
in Africa."
Among the constraints to fighting the epidemic
cited in the Maputo meeting is the inadequate
financial support currently available for
TB control. A large majority of African
countries that provided financial data to
WHO in 2003 reported funding gaps, including
eight of the nine countries with the highest
TB burden. Many national TB programmes are
relying extensively on grants from external
donor agencies, including the Global Fund
to Fight AIDS, TB and Malaria (GFATM). At
the same time, few African countries have
included TB in their poverty alleviation
strategies.
But more financial resources alone will
not solve the TB problem. Dedicated efforts
must also be made to strengthen health systems
and respond to the crisis of health workforce
attrition in the region. The specific actions
called for by the Regional Committee to
address the TB emergency are:
improve the quantity
and quality of staff involved in TB
control;
rapidly improve TB
case detection and treatment success
rates with expanded DOTS coverage at
national and district levels;
reduce the combined
TB patient default and transfer out
rates to 10% or less;
scale up interventions
to manage TB and HIV together, including
increased access to anti-retroviral
therapy for TB patients who are co-infected
with HIV, and to chemoprophylaxis against
TB for people with HIV;
expand national TB
partnerships, public-private collaboration
and community participation in TB control
activities.
In
the other four WHO regions of the world,
TB trends are either stable or in decline
and are on track to reach the MDG targets
of halving TB prevalence and deaths by 2015.